Results 1 to 10 of 11
I have been trying for too long to switch from the Nouveau driver to nvidia driver 173 (.14.37) on Linux Mint Mate without success. I have tried a manual install ...
Enjoy an ad free experience by logging in. Not a member yet? Register.
- 06-24-2013 #1
Anybody ever heard of or see a successful installatio of nVidia drive
In eveyr case the driver seems to get installed, but the X server will not start because it tells me (I think) that the xorg configuration file is invalid.
Since there appears to be no way of recovering from this situation, I have to re-install Mint - I'm not on my 16th install in the last 10 days.
Is there any evidence that this driver 173 has ever been successfully installed, anyway, in Mint Mate 15, replacing the Nouveau driver? If so, what has to be done - in detail?
- 06-24-2013 #2
- Join Date
- Apr 2012
- Virginia, USA
This thread seems to contain the answer: How to get Nvidia's proprietary driver to work - Linux Mint Community
Though, instead of updating GRUB, I recommend just blacklisting the module the old fashioned way Howto: Prevent a Linux kernel module from auto loading
- 06-25-2013 #3
Err, no, doesn't work - not even close. I tried this about a week ago. Waste of time.
This is starting to convince me that nobody has ever actually installed the 173 driver on a supported GeForce card under Mint 15. There are lots of people who give advice on various ways they THINK it (might) work, but I never saw a claim from anybody who has actually done it. I too can think of lots of ways that it might work; for about 100% of the time I am mistaken. So there's clearly a hole in the design of the driver and installation process when combined. Sadly, I don't think there' any chance of anybody ever responding to this defect.
Blacklisting the Nouveau driver confuses me too: after a clean install of Mint (yes, another one) there is no Nouveau module loaded into the Kernel according to lsmod output, so I can't see that blacklisting it is going to make any difference. But what do I know?
- 06-26-2013 #4
- Join Date
- Nov 2007
While I don't have an old Quadro card lying around, I just installed this driver into a Mint 15 Mate OS without issue. *If* you need to do everything via a GUI, this install will likely be beyond your comfort zone/ability.
1) Boot the OS
2) Right-click the desktop and open a terminal
3) Type in:
sudo service mdm stop
4) Type in:
sudo apt-get update && sudo apt-get install nvidia-173
5) Type in:
* The apt install automatically blacklists the nouveau driver, as evidenced (now) by the existence of: /etc/modprobe.d/nvidia-graphics-drivers.conf
* The nouveau driver is definitely a module - modinfo nouveau
* So is the nvidia driver - modinfo nvidia_173
* With newer versions of X.org, there is no xorg.conf file needed. If you install the driver and have display issues, then you likely need further tuning (possibly because your monitor does not support some auto-sensing/tuning.) To create an xorg.conf (if needed), run the command 'sudo nvidia-xconfig' and then reboot.
* If steps above are not detailed enough, I cannot help further.
- 06-26-2013 #5
Many thanks: the steps are clear enough and, significantly contain the word "should", as in "- The system will reboot and should now be using the Nvidia 173 driver".
Sadly, Mint, like most other software (system or otherwise) is not well versed in the social niceties of duty and obligation: the process you have described is, in principle, one of the many approaches I have tried to installing this driver - it is certainly the approach I have used most frequently. The system gets to the 'now reboot' step ok, but obstinately fails to come up with anything usable other than a CLI. X server throws a tantrum and tells me that my X system is not configured correctly and proceeds to tell me some of the things it finds wrong (none of which are a result of any decision I made or that I can influence in this install process). Running nvidia-xconfig makes no difference to the state of X Server'ss sense of dissatisfaction - including renaming the xorg.conf file before hand.
True: modprobe shows both modules you listed (but why doesn't 'nouveau' show in the output from lsmod?). I note that the nvidia-graphics-drivers.conf file also blacklists nvidia-173-updates - I wonder why?
But, the bottom line is that this process does not end up with a usable system: it requires a re-install of the OS again, i.e. a reversion to the noveau driver.
I should add that I have tried this process using 3 different monitors: a simple Dell E173FPc LCD, running (default) at 1280 x 1024 60 Hz. A Mitsubishi Diamond Pro 920 (using the Sony tube); this 19" CRT is capable of 1600 x 1200, up to 85 Hz. An Iiyama Vision Master Pro 454, 19" capable of 1920 X 1440 at 85 Hz.
- 06-26-2013 #6
I'm only running M15 on a VM so haven't installed the nvidia driver on it but since version 5 it has always worked so here are some thoughts to throw in to the mix.
Is 173 the correct driver, have you tried installing nvidia-current instead?
What are some of the things it finds wrong? Have a look in ~/.xsession-errors and /var/log/Xorg.0.log
Some of these are pretty old monitors.They may need a revival of the arcane art of mode lines and because I'm not entirely evil, a calculator
Just found this in which may also help. You will probably need to adjust the modeline and modes in the file to suit your monitor.[/edit]What do we want?
When do we want 'em?
Doesn't really matter does it!?
The Fifth Continent
- 06-26-2013 #7
Are you sure noveau is a module and not compiled into the kernel itself? That's one reason it wouldn't show up in the output of lsmod.
- 06-26-2013 #8
- Join Date
- Nov 2007
So I'll state the same thing again: *If* you need to do everything via a GUI, this install will likely be beyond your comfort zone/ability.
You have done no troubleshooting. The nouveau driver is a module - it *should not* be listed by lsmod because...it's not loaded by the kernel. Modinfo "module_name" returns info as expected, along with the location of the module. Following the steps above, you have installed the nvidia_173 module. If you have further problems, it is because your system has further problems/requires tuning. *Re-installing the OS to try another set of steps is NOT the answer.* If an xorg.conf file exists and is giving you problems, delete it. If it's not there, create one. Review the X.org log - find the errors and search Google on those errors. If you want to remove the nvidia_173 driver, use the 'apt-get remove' command. In short, you either commit to learning, understanding, and troubleshooting, or you accept that you cannot get this driver installed - whether it is a software/hardware issue. You have a very old video card on a very recent Linux distro. You may find that an older distro will better support the older HW "out of the box."
- 06-26-2013 #9
I wrote a long reply to this (no, not this, the one I was replying to - by elija) post, taking most of the day on & off. But this forum told me 'the token has expired' and through it all away. Nice work; thanks.
- 06-26-2013 #10