[leisa]

Hi.

I have a pair of 4GB USB flash drives that I can't use. To be specific, these drives can't be written to at all.

I've attempted most of the obvious things. I've tried to remove/reformat the FAT32 partitions using Gparted. Fdisk doesn't recognize the partitions at all. Cfdisk outputs that "Partition begins after end-of-disk," Dosfsck finds all sorts of errors on thee drives but refuses to correct them. Mkdosfs didn't do anything. I tried to zero-out the drives using DD to no avail. Ditto for badblocks.

There is a small amount of data (one file) on each of these drives but nothing important. I don't care about recovering the data. I just want to be able to make these drives usable again.

Anyone have any suggestions?

--Leisa

[HROAdmin26]

A) Do the USB sticks have a little switch on them (physically) that makes them read-only?

B) If not:

shred -vz -n 1 /dev/sdX

*Replace X with the correct drive from fdisk -l.

If that is failing, why? Check /var/log/messages, etc. I/O Error = HW problem.

[leisa]

Hi,

Originally Posted by HROAdmin26

A) Do the USB sticks have a little switch on them (physically) that makes them read-only?

There's no switch.

B) If not:

shred -vz -n 1 /dev/sdX

Tried it as you suggested. Got all sorts of I/O errors (as expected).

If that is failing, why? Check /var/log/messages, etc. I/O Error = HW problem.

Here's a sampling of the error messages in 'messages'.

Jun  8 19:29:09 laptop kernel: [256364.911826] sd 2:0:0:0: [sdb] Sense Key : Medium Error [current] 
Jun  8 19:29:09 laptop kernel: [256364.911831] sd 2:0:0:0: [sdb] Add. Sense: Cannot write medium - incompatible format
Jun  8 19:29:09 laptop kernel: [256364.911838] end_request: I/O error, dev sdb, sector 1007579
Jun  8 19:29:09 laptop kernel: [256364.924364] sd 2:0:0:0: [sdb] Result: hostbyte=DID_OK driverbyte=DRIVER_SENSE,SUGGEST_OK

It's worth noting that both of these drives went for a dump immediately after being inserted in (two different) Windows machines. This wasn't something that I thought important when the first one went several months ago but when the second one went down last week immediately after being used in an attempt to transfer data from my old XP laptop, I realized that these two incidents have something in common.

[HROAdmin26]

Not much else to do. The write command being issued to the device is failing with a HW error message.

SCSI Sense Codes => Cannot write medium - incompatible format

[leisa]

Yeah. I had a feeling that these drives were toast. Wish I knew exactly what caused it though.

Thanks anyway.

--Leisa

[theriach]

Did you tried changing the file system?
My Linux Notebook: Problem Writing to USB Flash Drive on Linux

[leisa]

Yes...

...but changing the file system requires writing to the drive.

[kopete]

Are these drives brand new? It's hard to believe they're toast already.

I bought a USB Flash drive recently and can use it fine in Linux.

Did you try booting up your OS and then inserting the USB flash drive afterwards?

Which Linux OS are you using? You could even test in on a LiveCD.

If you use an off-shoot Debian OS, you could try.... System -> Monitoring -> kdiskfree or kwikdisk (or System -> Applications -> kwikdisk)

See if the application 'sees it.' GParted should be able to see it, though. Try using other usb ports as well.

For some reason, it might not be mounting.

[leisa]

Originally Posted by kopete

Are these drives brand new? It's hard to believe they're toast already.

They're almost new.

Did you try booting up your OS and then inserting the USB flash drive afterwards?

Yes.

See if the application 'sees it.' GParted should be able to see it, though. Try using other usb ports as well.

I can see these drives in Gparted. I can go through the motions of deleting /changing the file system or formatting the drives. But Gparted won't actually carry out the commands.

Mounting these drives isn't the problem. They mount just fine. I can read them. I just can't write to them in any way, regardless of operating system.

As I mentioned earlier in this thread, they initially worked fine in Linux. Only after I tried to use the drives to transfer files from Windows machines did they break.

[kopete]

Originally Posted by leisa

They're almost new.

I can see these drives in Gparted. I can go through the motions of deleting /changing the file system or formatting the drives. But Gparted won't actually carry out the commands.

Mounting these drives isn't the problem. They mount just fine. I can read them. I just can't write to them in any way, regardless of operating system.

As I mentioned earlier in this thread, they initially worked fine in Linux. Only after I tried to use the drives to transfer files from Windows machines did they break.

Windows machines? XP? Vista? Were the files in a partition using NTFS format or FAT32? If it was NTFS, your Linux OS needs ntfs-3g installed. I think Ubuntu has it installed by default but I'm not sure. It could be part of the problem, perhaps.

You're saying you can't write to the usb drives in Linux from Linux either anymore? I would find out which /dev/sdXn (where X is the letter and n the number designation) Ubuntu is assigning it and try to create a directory for it. Then try to write something to it. Try doing it as root.

I would look at that and then go from there (eventually, you'll want to format but perhaps, see if there's any issues there?).