Proposal for multi-redirecting stdout & stderr to different programs

Here I am proposing to the entire Linux community that OS designer might consider doing this:
the stdio's pipe operator '|' should work the same as '>', and should support multi-pipe,

for example,
MyProgramA 1>A_stdout.txt 2>A_stderr.txt 1>A_stdout2.txt 2>B_stderr2.txt 1|MyProgramB 1|MyProgramC 2|MyProgramD

the standard output from MyProgramA is written into 2 files A_stdout.txt and A_stdout2.txt , in addition, it's piped into MyProgramB and MyProgramC, its error output is piped into MyProgramD

However, one problem of this design is that if there are multiple '|'s, there'll be ambiguity on the 2nd and subsequent '|'s, i.e. do you want to pipe the stdout/err from the 1st program or the 2nd program? Maybe we can bracket them i.e.
MyProgramA 1|(MyProgramB 1>B.stdout 2>B.stderr) 2|(MyProgramC 1>C.stdout 2>C.stderr)

In fact, multi-pipe is not required if we use the command 'tee',
but is simpler, because instead of writing:
MyProgram | tee file1 | tee file2 | tee file3 >file4
we can write:
MyProgram 1>file1 1>file2 1>file3 1>file4

What do you guys think?:D

Wang Xuancong

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by xuancong

Here I am proposing to the entire Linux community that OS designer might consider doing this:
the stdio's pipe operator '|' should work the same as '>', and should support multi-pipe,

for example,
MyProgramA 1>A_stdout.txt 2>A_stderr.txt 1>A_stdout2.txt 2>B_stderr2.txt 1|MyProgramB 1|MyProgramC 2|MyProgramD

the standard output from MyProgramA is written into 2 files A_stdout.txt and A_stdout2.txt , in addition, it's piped into MyProgramB and MyProgramC, its error output is piped into MyProgramD

However, one problem of this design is that if there are multiple '|'s, there'll be ambiguity on the 2nd and subsequent '|'s, i.e. do you want to pipe the stdout/err from the 1st program or the 2nd program? Maybe we can bracket them i.e.
MyProgramA 1|(MyProgramB 1>B.stdout 2>B.stderr) 2|(MyProgramC 1>C.stdout 2>C.stderr)

In fact, multi-pipe is not required if we use the command 'tee',
but is simpler, because instead of writing:
MyProgram | tee file1 | tee file2 | tee file3 >file4
we can write:
MyProgram 1>file1 1>file2 1>file3 1>file4

What do you guys think?:D

Wang Xuancong

---

The piping both "|" and ">" have been part of UNIT since 1973. As such there is too much written that the definitions will not be changing.

The idea dates back to the latter half of the 1950s and was irst suggested by M. Doug McIlroy (Bell Labs). See their history page at: The Creation of the UNIX* Operating System: Connecting streams like a garden hose

You might want to look at the commands "tee" and "exec" as well.

For some really weird "redirection" usage you can look in the "FAQ --- Csh Programming Considered Harmful" at http://www.faqs.org/faqs/unix-faq/shell/csh-whynot/ where they are showing missing stuff in the "C shell" (csh or tcsh).


Unix started in 1969 and Linux is build with the Unix tool set and the kernel layer is Linux. So the design has many decades of use prior to some one just finding it.