ARTICLE

Ubuntu 6.06 Review
Contributed by Clement Lefebvre in Reviews on 2006-06-02 08:17:47
Page 2 of 3

Inside Ubuntu

Speed

This first thing I noticed about Dapper was that it was faster. It took me 53 seconds from the BIOS to GDM, 12 seconds for Gnome to be fully operational and 22 seconds to shutdown the computer. It's all relative of course, and nobody has the same hardware configuration. My computer though is very small (10.6") and it's using an ULV processor which runs as slowly as possible in order no to create too much heat and to save 6 hours of battery life. On that laptop, I haven't seen any distribution boot that fast. As I remember SUSE 10.1 took me more than 2 minutes to boot. I don't want to say anything more about that, a proper benchmark would be more appropriate, but I thought it deserved to be mentioned.

Artwork

The defaut Ubuntu desktop

The new artwork is very impressive and I like it a lot. Since its first release Ubuntu was brown when all others were blue. It was one of its numerous controversial innovations. I liked it then already. In Dapper, the theme was made brighter with touches of orange and flashy icons. People will either hate it or love it, I guess. It gives an overall welcoming and warm impression. I also think it looks quite professional. With it comes a set of nice and pleasant sounds, funny and yet not overwhelming.

For those who definitely do not want their desktop to be brown, Ubuntu also comes with a set of beautiful alternative themes, such as ClearLooks, IndustrialTango, Outdoors, Resilience and Silicon. Also, nice Ubuntu wallpapers are included in the distribution so you don't have to go and search gnome-look.org for a replacement.

The IndustrialTango theme and an alternative Ubuntu wallpaper

Hardware Recognition

Most of my hardware was properly configured. I have a Centrino laptop which usually has issues with Linux on the following things:

  • The Sony Memory Stick Pro reader is usually not recognized and it wasn't recognized by Dapper either.
  • The ALPS touchpad is usually not set correctly. It wasn't set correctly on Dapper either, although I simply added SHMConfig to /etc/X11/xorg.conf, troubleshooted with synclient and I was then able to fix the problem.
  • The sound card is usually silent due to an External Amplifier switch turned on by default. It was the same problem in Dapper. It is very easy to fix though and I believe it has nothing to do with Ubuntu.
  • The wireless card, an iwp2200 is usually not recognized. It was by Dapper and it worked perfectly.
  • The graphics card, an i855, is usually not configured for its widescreen resolution (1280x768). The only distribution that supports this by default is SUSE 10.1. In Dapper, it wasn't. However, the package i915resolution was included in the official repositories, and installing it and simply restarting X fixed the problem.

Everything else worked out of the box. And the issues mentioned above didn't take much time to solve.

Default set of Applications

Dapper Drake comes with a really nice set of applications, such as:

  • OpenOffice 2.0.2
  • Firefox 1.5.0.3
  • Evolution 2.6.1
  • Ekiga 2.01
  • Gaim 1.5.1
  • The Gimp 2.2.11
Dapper comes with Firefox 1.5 and OpenOffice 2.0

It also comes with a selection of small games (that I see in every distribution and that I've never played actually...), some multimedia players and audio tools, a 2.6.15 kernel and some accessories. Together with Gnome 2.14.1 (which now offers networking and CD/DVD creation features), it provides a single application for all your basic needs. The menus are consistent, well organized and you can easily edit them thanks to an application called Alacarte Menu Editor.

The Alcacarte Menu Editor

I noticed that sendmail was not installed by default and this is a pity. More and more ISP stop providing their users with an SMTP server and it is not always easy for the novice user to configure it himself on his machine. I was sorry to see that no IRC client was installed, or at least made visible in the menus. There surely are better clients than Gaim for that, and IRC has become a very important protocol for community support. The channels are even presented on the official Ubuntu website, so why not give the user an easy way to access them?

Multimedia support

I am convinced that a distribution should not include support for restricted formats by default. If they are patented, proprietary, commercial, then they shouldn't be installed on the user's behalf. Having said that, a lot of us were victims of vendor-locking and now have no choice but to use MP3 and read encrypted DVDs. Hopefully this will change in the future, but at the moment, it is up to the GNU/Linux distributions not to include these technologies by default, but also to make their installation as easy as possible for those among us who need them.

By default, Ubuntu doesn't play restricted formats and Totem doesn't read DVDs

In this matter, Ubuntu has a noble approach. It doesn't play restricted formats by default, but it provides great documentation on how to add support for these formats. This covers various things such as MP3, encrypted DVD playback, Flash, RealMedia, DivX...etc:

https://wiki.ubuntu.com/RestrictedFormats

Networking

As it turned out, my wife runs Windows on her computer and she has shared folders on it (I don't think she knows about that though). This was the perfect opportunity to see if Ubuntu would spot them. And it did. I didn't have to set up anything, I wasn't even asked what "workgroup" or "domain" I was a member of... I clicked on Places->Network Servers->Windows Network->Galaxy (which is both the name of the Windows workgroup and my Wireless ESSID, I suppose it was the Workgroup that was shown here)->Sun (which is the name of my wife's computer) and there I was, browsing through her shared folders.

Browsing the Windows network shares

In SUSE 10.1 it worked as well, but I had to configure the firewall and give the workgroup name. And even then, I could only access her shared folders by directly pointing to her IP address through the smb:// kio protocol.

In Dapper, you can also "connect" to a remote computer and create a linked folder on your desktop which will represent the remote file system and act as if it was mounted. This is extremely powerful, and you can use it on FTP servers, SMB shares, SSH, HTTP and HTTPS servers.

Browsing the Windows network shares

Package Management

Package managers got better and better in GNU/Linux distributions. Rug, in the recent SUSE 10.1 for instance is full of nice features that are not present in APT. However a lot of people still consider APT to be the best. The reason for this is simple: the packages are stable, there is a huge number of them and APT is fast and reliable.

In Dapper, a little applet was introduced in the Gnome desktop, which only appears when updates become available in the repositories. This is a nice feature. Also, an Add/Remove application was added to provide ease of use to novice users. This application even has the ability to show unsupported and commercial applications which are out of the scope of the enabled repositories, and to enable a repository when one of these applications is selected for install.

The new Add/Remove application and the Synaptic Package Manager

Finally, the Synaptic GUI and the aptitude console tool are still there. There are also very easy to use, very fast and reliable. It is hard to find anything bad to say about Ubuntu's package management.



Article Index
Ubuntu 6.06 Review
Inside Ubuntu
Conclusion
 
Discussion(s)
Excellant Review
Written by remo on 2006-06-02 11:23:33
Your review makes me feel i've gotta make some space to install dapper. Myself being a longtime gentoo fan. Still i would like to test dapper out. Great review to a great distribution.
Discuss! Reply!

Wonderful distro
Written by Henrik on 2006-06-02 18:50:41
The networking features have really gotten an overhaul in this release. On the last release I had trouble surfing the LAN without some mingling, now it works out of the box, wonderful.

World of Warcraft also runs alot better in wine now, though I don't know if that's an improvement on wine's part or ubuntu's.

And to even further discredit my Linux-knowledge, Ubuntu was my first go at Linux, I feel almost ashamed for not trying out other distros, but heck, if it works the way I want to I don't see a reason to switch :-)
Discuss! Reply!

IRC client
Written by voksi on 2006-06-03 01:50:41
After instalation you can user Gaim for IRC or irssi - text based IRC client. Probably, the best there is. You can use them in Live session too.
Discuss! Reply!

excelent review, even better os
Written by pilly on 2006-06-03 02:45:58
I don't think I could ask for a better os for my laptop. Hands down the best one I've found bar none. I belive in using the BEST tool for the job (I also have a mepis file server, and a gentoo media server desktop/myth frontend) and dapper is pleasnt to look at and snappy. And I don't usually like gnome, still I find it more portable than kde. dapper has really raised the bar... thank-you to everyone that helped in creating it... easy to see why it's the most popular. keep up the good work.

if you have an older laptop, like I do (presario 700
1.3 Ghz) you owe yourself to check it out. All it'll cost you is a blank disk.
Discuss! Reply!

Gentoo fan - Me too
Written by Eddie303 on 2006-06-03 03:31:22
Hey, I used Gentoo on my desktop, but now on my new laptop I run Dapper, and it is way less to fiddle with it, the single problem is that Dapper does not have as many packages as Gentoo has in portage, that was important to me... The other thing... I already tried to sbstitute Gentoo with Breezy, but I could not make lirc to work, on my desktop I used it to control tvtime and xmms...
Discuss! Reply!

Dapper Drake
Written by Pieter on 2006-06-03 05:18:37
I have used all the Ubuntu distro's to date. mostly out of interest due to the SA connection, but also because I like the idea of choice (MS or Linux) and the principles of open source software.

I have a selection of about 30 distros at home which I continuously update and test (on VMware) and this must be one of the easiest and most complete distro's I have ever used.

I know it is a bit unfair under VMware as it is a defined environment, but I tried the live CD on my Siemens Fujitsu T4010 TapbletPC and it worked mostly out of the box, other than for the TabletPC pen, which after a reasonably simple fix (Thanks Google), even that worked. Sound, WiFi, Pad Mouse etc, and this is a reasonably new laptop version!

Great distro, and a really nice review, not too technical and written in the ubuntu flavour (ie not condascending)

Thanks for your efforts
Discuss! Reply!

What about Hibernate and Suspend??
Written by José Pinto on 2006-06-04 07:36:35
Your review is very good but I was intrigued why didn't you mention what is, for me, the best desktop improvement: The ability to Suspend, Hibernate and Switch between user sessions.
I have an HP dv1255ea and all the drivers (including sound, 3D, wi-fi and card reader) we're successfully installed.
Also, Ubuntu nows mounts existing NTFS drives by default.
Discuss! Reply!

Too many changes in only six weeks
Written by Cristian on 2006-06-04 11:27:37
I've been using ubuntu for a year now, and it rocks. I use it as my desktop, on servers and even in a cluster enviroment for physical simulations.
But the last week when i saw the changes of Dapper RC, i felt frustrated, the delay of six weeks, that was intented for the final polish of ubuntu, translations, artwork, bugfixes, was used for adding a new installation method with a graphical installer?. I think it do not match the objectives of a long term support release, it throws away all the polish work done before.
I think the new installer is the right direction to take, it's faster and graphical, but it was introduced in the six weeks for polishing the system. It's a huge change and it's not tested like the rest of the release. I think the delay weeks where for adding this installer, not for making the system more stable. If you pay attention you can see that the whole system is very clean and eye candy, but the installer is far away from being at the same point, i even discovered a bug, not critical, but it shows the inmaturity of the application. If you make a partition and then you right click it for "moving or resize" and change the size by writing the numbers in the spin box insted of clicking the arrows that adds or substracts a unit to the value it holds you don't get enabled the apply button, but if you click one of the arrows it enables it.
How can this be a LTS release with an installer tested for only a week, and with a GUI bug on it?
It seems far more stable the flight CD 7, with the old Live CD and Installation CD.
Discuss! Reply!

LIRC
Written by Major Lockup on 2006-06-04 12:18:05
Lirc in ubuntu is not as it should be indeed. It was a bitch setting up microsoft's remote (usb_mce2 is not included!).
Discuss! Reply!

What about Hibernate and Suspend??
Written by Ian on 2006-06-04 14:09:48
I just installed 6.06 on my Toshiba A45-S120 laptop. Suspend and Hibernate work fine! Only problem I have found is that when it suspends I lose my wireless connection until I reboot.
Discuss! Reply!

16.000 packages
Written by Camilo on 2006-06-04 15:51:05
Did you look at http://packages.ubuntu.com ?
Discuss! Reply!

Re: Too many changes in only six weeks
Written by James on 2006-06-05 15:42:42
The installer has been tested for over a month. I remember seeing it way back in flight 6, might have been around before then.

Also, far, far more then the installer was worked on during that six week period. Having downloaded a total of well over a gigabyte of updates from flight 6 to release, I'd say pretty much everything got tweaked. Most of it was "under the hood", but surly you can see the speed difference between breezy and dapper? A huge portion of that optimization happened during the final 6 weeks of dev. I remember at least one update where it was announced 10 seconds of boot time had been eliminated.

Oh, and there was a lot of new artwork and theme changes done within those 6 weeks also.
Discuss! Reply!

Am i the only one REALLY unsatisfied?
Written by Michele on 2006-06-06 18:17:56
(first of all excuse the bad english, i'm italian!)

Well, the upgrade to dapper has just f****d up ALL of my 3 breezy boxes. A lot of programs that used to work with breezy (mplayer, totem, videolan, skype, openoffice) just get frozen up, cups and the samba shares browser don't work ON BOTH my laptop and my desktop. And mldonkey on my server gives quirky errors and refuses to get removed...

Really nothing serious, indeed, but alle these bugs left me a feeling of something unstable and still immature, and a really bad mood, so i think i'll get back to my good old debian for the server and suse for the desktops.
Discuss! Reply!

Needs better wifi tools
Written by fuji on 2006-06-07 07:54:58
Setting up a wireless connection with WPA2 security on a bcm43xx chipset is a nightmare. You end up using the console to set things up. This should be automatic, like on Mandriva.
Discuss! Reply!

Re: Am i the only one REALLY unsatisfied
Written by on 2006-06-09 13:30:12
Who's fault is that? You didn't test the upgrade on a test box or in a virtual PC situation using something like the freely available VMware Server. You went ahead and blindly upgraded your PCs that were basically "production machines". And then you complain about it!
Discuss! Reply!

ah
Written by Dan on 2006-10-29 19:55:32
ahahaha, you jerk
Discuss! Reply!

Where/How do I?....
Written by Ricky J on 2006-06-11 16:32:41
Where do I download a full desktop version of this ubuntu 6.06 that installs with no hitches, including the wireless card drivers for my laptop?
I must not be geeky enough...I have trouble with all linux products going to this cmd line that I don't know what to do with. What do I do with that!? Any help you coul give would be greatly apriciated. Thanks
Discuss! Reply!

Ricky, this isn't the place to ask for
Written by Nate on 2006-06-13 22:33:59
The CD for installing a full desktop version of Ubuntu Dapper Drake (which is version 6.06) can be found at http://mirror.cs.umn.edu/ubuntu-releases/6.06/

You probably have an intel x86 computer.

Burn that ISO file to a CD and use it to boot your computer.

As for problems with your wireless card and linux in general, I'd suggest you go to http://www.ubuntuforums.org

But don't just post on there. First find out what kind of wireless card you have, and search for it on the forum. If you have a problem, it may have already been discovered by someone else with the same hardware, and fixed! Usually, hardware problems can be remedied with a bit of scavenging for knowledge.

As for the command line, it's in no way necessary to learn to use the command line to use linux, so it's okay to be resistant to use it! But just so you know, learning the command line takes a bit of work at first, but makes things very easy! The command line is so useful once you know how to use it. Feel free to shy away it, you'll be able to survive fine without it. I just suggest you give learning it a shot, it provides you with all sorts of valuable tools in running linux.
Discuss! Reply!

Re: Too many changes in only six weeks
Written by Matt Zimmerman on 2006-06-14 21:45:21
The new installer was a key planned feature of the 6.06 LTS release from the beginning, and was by no means added during the delay.
Discuss! Reply!

Re: Am i the only one REALLY unsatisfied
Written by RatFink on 2006-06-17 18:01:49
Sure it's his fault he caused himself grief by not testing, however as he stated a lot of the problems were not show stoppers and even the best testing cannot find everything. Secondly VMware has a hardware configuration vastly different then most PCs so it isn’t the smartest thing to test something on. But I don't see him complaining much about that other then him being disappointed. But the problems he is having according to him stemmed from the distribution. If the upgrade is broken it may be something he can fix himself but it doesn't help others looking to upgrade.
Discuss! Reply!

I have a M400 and... proble with the pen
Written by carlo on 2006-06-24 01:41:15
What is the fix for the pen... perhaps it could work in my toshiba m400 too... thx
Discuss! Reply!

Which config did you go with ?
Written by Kukania13 on 2006-06-26 22:47:28
I have the same wireless chipset on my laptop, bcm43xx; even though Ubuntu 5 offered driver for dis chip in their recent kernel I couldn't get it running. The only way I could use wireless with this chip was by running ndiswrapper 1.8! Could you tell me if you got it running , with this distro version ? and how ?
Many thanks.
Discuss! Reply!

memory stick reader does not work
Written by Nuno Silva on 2006-10-21 07:56:32
Hi,

I'm really happy with Ubuntu 6.06 distro too.

However, I could't manage to put the memory stick card reader to work.

However, you say:

> Everything else worked out of the box. And the issues mentioned above didn't take much time to solve.

Can you please explain what did you do to put the memory stick to work?

Best.
Discuss! Reply!

floppy support
Written by Nick on 2007-02-08 13:47:26
Ubuntu 6.06 was the first Linux distro that worked almost out of the box on my machine (I had to search for an ATI driver to make the refreshment rate usable though). Thanks to it I understood the basics of Linux and Software Libre philosophy and finally stopped using M$ software. The only thing which is still bothering me is the absence of floppy support -- this release does not read them properly and corrupts them often. I understand that floppies are nearly extinct nowadays, still some people need this backward compatibility.
Discuss! Reply!

this is how I used Drive Image 2002 with
Written by Avt on 2007-08-10 00:40:43
after putting back a (drive image 2002) backup this is how to repair Ubuntu Inode error seen as a popup from Dapper on bootup:



Boot to ubuntu Dapper live cd then

sudo su to become root then type:

umount /dev/sda7 return

fsck.ext3 -f /dev/sda7 return

fsck.ext3 /dev/sda7 return

mkdir /mnt/sda7; mount /dev/sda7/mnt/sda7
Discuss! Reply!

help
Written by kaeli on 2008-06-30 13:47:35
please explain to me how to install adobe flash player
Discuss! Reply!